Theories of Personal Identity

Refer to Stich and Donaldson book, Chapter 11.

Do NOT use the internet as a source. Use the Stich and Donaldson textbook only.

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Custom Essay on
Theories of Personal Identity
From as low as $9/Page
Order Essay


Write 4 paragraphs (approximately 500 words) about the following case:

Suppose that Garrett, a 35-year-old man, robs a bank and kills one of the bank guards. While driving away from the scene of the crime, Garrett loses control of his car and crashes into a brick wall. He is not wearing a seat belt, and he sustains a serious head injury which results in a total and permanent loss of memory of everything that has happened for the last 3 years. There is no chance he will ever regain his memory of these 3 years. A year after the robbery, Garrett is brought to trial.

Question: What would a memory theorist say about this case? Is the man on trial numerically identical with the man who robbed the bank? Is the man on trial morally responsible for the bank robbery and the murder? What would a soul theorist say?

Include the following:

1. Define and explain ONE of the Memory Theories of Personal Identity (version 1, version 2, or version 3 from Stich and Donaldson Ch. 11). Definitions should be in quotation marks, word-for-word, followed by a citation. Briefly explain this Memory Theory of personal identity.

2. Explain what a Memory Theorist of personal identity would say about the Garrett case. What would their position be, and why?

3. Explain what a Soul Theorist of personal identity would say about the Garrett case.  What would their position be, and why?

4. Explain why the Soul Theorist and Memory Theorist might disagree about the Garrett case.

*Include MLA in-text citations  download(author  page number). Include bibliography at the end.

Order Now Image

Tips and Requirements:

* Write in formal style with paragraphs that connect with signposting. Each paragraph should have one main focus. See Professional Writing Skills: Structure

* Read your paper out loud to someone or yourself to check for grammar mistakes.

* See  “APA citation HELPSHEET .pdf”  for how to include citations and bibliography.

*Explain sufficiently and clearly, as if you were explaining these ideas to someone who has not read the material.

*Explain short quotes fully. See Professional Writing: Quotations

* Upload the file. Use doc, docx, rtf, or pdf format. For more information on Theories of Personal Identity check out:

The Homework Writings
Order NOW For A 10% Discount!
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Our Advantages

Plagiarism Free Papers’s team of writers write all papers from scratch. We deliver 100% original, unique papers. That’s what makes us the best custom homework writing service

Free Revisions

We provide unlimited free revisions to all customers and on all papers. Try The Homework Writings today for the best custom homework writing service and experience in the industry.

Title-page gives clients title pages free of charge. Your only job is to fill out our order form. We will handle the rest.


As the leading essay writing service, we never submit any paper without a reference/bibliography page. We do this free of charge too.

Originality & Security

At, we take great pride in delivering only high-quality 100% original papers to all our clients. We also never share any of our clients’ information with third parties. Your data is safe with us.

24/7 Customer Support

No other custom homework writing service has a friendly, always available customer support team to respond to clients like us.

Try it now!

Calculate the price of your order

We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Why outsource our services

We have the best customer support team for your essay writing needs.


Flexible Pricing

You won’t find any other custom homework writing service with pricing as flexible and affordable as ours.


Admission help & Client-Writer Contact

We provide a direct line of communication with our writers for the best writing experience.


Paper Submission

As the leading custom homework writing service, we take deadlines very seriously. You will have your paper submitted on time without any delays.


Customer Feedback

We truly value your feedback, good or bad, and always use your feedback to help us provide you with an even better custom homework writing service