How to write a critical essay step by step

How to write a critical essay step by step

Have you ever agreed or disagreed with an author of a book you have read? Do you give your opinion after watching an interesting movie?

If you have ever done this, you performed a critical analysis of what you read or watched. This is what you are required to do when writing a critical essay. A critical analysis essay is an academic paper where you analyze and evaluate another person’s work.

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Custom Essay on
How to write a critical essay step by step
From as low as $9/Page
Order Essay

You can critique text like a book, an interesting movie, a painting, or an article and interpret its position. You can give your opinion and say whether you agree or disagree with an author and provide evidence to back up your claim.

What is critical analysis?

Critical analysis is when you read a text or watch a movie and provide a response to the central theme. You need to give an opinion and provide evidence to support it.

This means you break down the material you are analyzing and study each aspect of it. After performing an in-depth analysis, you need to evaluate how the author communicates their message.

Look at the strengths and weaknesses of the author’s work. Ensure you do the following when performing your critical analysis

  • Provide a thesis statement
  • Expresses what an author intended to communicate
  • Describes techniques an author uses to pass his or her message

How to write a critical analysis

Critical writing requires you to thoroughly read and understand the provided source document before you can start your analysis. Make sure you know the theme of the source material and the evidence provided.

Break down the material you are analyzing into smaller sections. This helps to make the analysis process easier. Study each part to provide critical response essays. In your response, you will assess the strengths and weaknesses of the source document.

How to write a critical analysis essay

A critical essay is a type of assignment that is common in universities and colleges. Your instructor will give you this assignment to build your critical thinking skills, evaluation skills, writing skills, and research skills.

You are expected to produce a well-written critical analysis essay with clear arguments and accurate evidence. Your response paper should be consistent and grammatically correct. The following is a step by step guide on how to write a critical analysis essay.

1.     Examine and understand your source material

You need to understand what you intend to analyze. Whether it is a book, a painting, or a movie, take time to examine and understand it.

For example, if your source material is a book or an article, you need to read it critically. This should be the first step of writing your critical essay.

Critical reading requires you to take notes of important points you need to include in your paper. Some of the things you can pay attention to and note down are the instruments of communication that the author uses in the text.

Look at the stylistic devices and note them down. Write what you think the author wanted to say, the words, and the grammar used in the text.

Think about questions that can help your analysis process and find answers in the text. Write down the questions and answers.

2.     Organize your work

Find the topic and problem an author is trying to solve in the text. Identify the author’s thesis statement, which is the central message.

Look for evidence supporting the central message and write them down. Identify what differentiates this piece of work from other similar texts.

Have a brainstorming session that will help you come up with information about the text. Write a list that comprises what you think about the text, what you know, and how you feel.

Put all your thoughts on paper and organize them. Arrange all your ideas and perform research in areas that you need more clarity and evidence.

Look at various places you can find useful information. For example, check scholarly articles, online databases, or reviews that will help you understand your original material better.

3.     Write your critical essay thesis statement

Create a strong thesis statement for your critical essay. Your thesis will be the guide for writing your critical essay.

Look at the information you have gathered when reading your source document and the information from your research work. This information should help you to develop a clear and concise thesis statement.

Your thesis should state the main idea of your paper. This is the central message that you will talk about in your entire paper.

It should give readers a preview of the message you are discussing. It should also present a unique argument that someone can oppose and provide a counter-argument. When writing a thesis statement, it is essential to find out what you are trying to prove.

4.     Create an analysis essay outline

Similar to other types of essays, you need to create an outline when you want to write your critical essay. A critical essay outline helps you organize your work, remember the most significant points, and write your paper faster.

It is the road map that you need to produce logical arguments that will not confuse your audience. An outline helps you to organize your evidence and decide which arguments come first and which one will be presented last. Here is how you can structure your work using a critical essay outline.

Analytical essay outline

Most essays follow the standard outline, which has five sections. These sections are an introduction paragraph, three body paragraphs, and a conclusion paragraph.

An essay outline helps you to organize your thoughts so that your audience can follow your trail of reasoning.  Perform research online and check out critical essay examples. See how they are structured.

When writing a critical essay, you can use this standard structure.  This is what you should produce.

Introduction paragraph

This is the first part of your critical essay. It is important to pay attention to this section. Your introduction will determine whether an audience will continue reading your work or stop as soon as they start.

Make sure you captivate your readers in the first sentence of your introduction. Start this paragraph in an interesting way and entice your audience to continue reading.

You can use an anecdote, a rhetorical question, shocking statistics, or an interesting statement to lure your audience. After writing your hook, you need to give background information about your topic and its significance.

Remember to introduce the author and the work you will be analyzing. Include the author’s primary idea. The final part of your introduction paragraph should be one or two sentences of your thesis statement.

Body paragraph

The body paragraph is the main section of your critical essay. It is where you present your arguments and defend your thesis statement.

The paragraphs in the body sections have arguments that include evidence and examples to justify your sub-point. Each point you discuss in this section should be connected to your central message, which is your thesis statement.

The first section of your body paragraph is a summary. Provide a short summary of the work you are evaluating.

Make sure your summary is objective, concise, and unbiased. Write about the position of the author and the evidence that supports this position.

Do not provide your personal opinion in this section. Write your summary in third person narrative. Look at different critical analysis essay examples and get insights on how to write your critical essay summary.

The second part of your body paragraph is where you analyze and evaluate your source material. For example, when analyzing a book, you will look at the strongest and weakest sections of the book. You can check the following points

  • The accuracy of the text you are analyzing
  • Check to see if key terms are defined
  • Find out if there are controversies.
  • Examine the work and find out if there are hidden assumptions.
  • Check the author’s language.
  • Is the text fair, or are there any biases?
  • Examine the organization of the author’s work. Is it logical? Are all points presented?
  • Check the author’s arguments and finds out if there are any gaps
  • Examine the language and find out if the author is too emotional, simple, or general.

After performing an in-depth analysis, it is time to present your opinion regarding the author’s work. Find out what you agree with and what you do not agree with in the source document.

Identify areas you feel the author is wrong and where you think they are right. Identify the feelings you have towards the source material. Do you think it is credible?

Conclusion paragraph

When concluding your critical essay, do it in an impactful way. Ensure it is brief and meaningful.

Remind readers of the significance of your topic, highlight your main points and summarize your work. Your conclusion should

  • Restate your thesis statement
  • Remind your audience of the importance of your analysis
  • Emphasize the source material strengths and weaknesses
  • State what makes the work unique

5.     Write your critical essay draft

After creating your outline, you can begin writing your draft. Begin your critical essay with a summary and proceed to present your arguments.

Write a detailed analysis and evaluation of your source material. Present evidence from the text you are analyzing and give examples where necessary.

You can look at an evaluation essay example and get more insight on how to present an argument. Do not copy another person’s work or ideas, instead, write your critical essay using your own style.

The example should only provide insight. Emphasize your main points as you conclude your critical essay.

Your essay should be objective, concise, and use formal language. When writing your paragraphs, use transitions. They make your workflow, and readers can follow your trail of thought.

6.     Edit and proofread your work

This is an essential step after writing your critical analysis essay. You do not want to submit a paper full of mistakes and lower your grade.

After the critical analysis essay writing, read it. Correct all grammar, spelling, and punctuation errors.

Check your sentence structure and workflow. Make sure you make adjustments where needed.

Check the evidence you have provided and the critical essay examples. They should be relevant and appropriately placed in your essay.

Step away from your work for a few hours or days. This will give you a mental break you need before you can proofread your work again.

When you read through your work with a fresh mind, you will discover mistakes that you could not see before. Ask a trusted friend or classmate to read your critical essay and give their views.

When your friend or classmate reads your critical analysis essay, they will give their views from a reader’s perspective. Consider their opinions and make adjustments where needed.

7.     Include References

Correctly cite your sources to avoid cases of plagiarism. Ask your instructor the formatting style you should use in case it is not indicated in the assignment instructions.

Common formatting styles in colleges and universities are APA, Chicago, Harvard, and MLA. You can check critical essay examples to see how these styles have been applied. Make sure you properly quote your work to get full marks in this section.

Critical thinking essay format

When writing your critical essay, you have to ensure it follows the correct format. Here is what you must include in each section of your paper

Introduction section

Your introduction must have a hook, background information, and a thesis statement. Include information about your topic and the name of the author of your source material. You should provide publication information about the text you will analyze.

Body paragraph

Each body paragraph should have a topic sentence. Discuss the topic sentence and provide evidence and examples from the text you are analyzing.

The last part of each paragraph should have a concluding sentence that ends a point and transitions a reader to the next point in a different paragraph. Each paragraph in your body section should be connected to your main idea, which is your thesis statement.

Research and look at different critical thinking essays examples to find inspiration on how to write an effective critical essay. Ensure your body paragraph addresses the following

  • A summary of the source document
  • The author’s organization and style
  • Analysis, evaluation, and interpretation of the source material
  • Author’s effectiveness in meeting his or her objectives and in appealing to an audience

Conclusion section

The last paragraph of your paper should restate your thesis statement. Remember to paraphrase it instead of copying it word for word from the introduction section.

Highlight your main points and evidence. End your essay with a concluding sentence that connects back to your title. Remember to include the following specific information in your critical essay conclusion section

  • Remind readers of the significance of your topic
  • Summarize the overall strengths and the weaknesses of your source text
  • Provide a final statement

Techniques in critiquing literature

There are various techniques you can use to analyze and evaluate text. You can choose one or more methods depending on your objective. The following are techniques you can use to critique any author’s work

Objective analysis is a technique you can use to evaluate text based on evidence and facts. This technique does not involve emotions or feelings.

A traditional critiquing technique depends on the collective agreement of source materials. These sources should be well known by educated and literate people.

The new critique technique is an evaluation style that concentrates only on the text you are analyzing. This method pays attention to irony, ambiguity, paradox, or metaphor that the author uses in the text.

Marxist criticism is another technique that uses analogy in evaluating text. It is mostly used to understand literature.

A metaphoric critiquing style focuses on how an author has used metaphor in a text. Taking a deeper look at metaphor in the text helps to better understand the message that the author is trying to convey.

You can evaluate a piece of literature based on the historical value it provides. This kind of critiquing technique is known as new historicism.

Try to understand an author’s mind using the psychological critiquing technique. This style involves analyzing an author’s unconscious wishes.

Another technique for evaluating text is social criticism. This involves focusing on how society functions are represented in the text. You can also look at how the text you are evaluating fits in society.

Moral criticism, also known as ethical criticism, helps judge an author’s work based on morals from the text. You can choose to focus on specific moral values.

Critical essay topics

Choosing a topic for your essay is an important step in writing an excellent critical analysis essay. Most times, your instructor will provide a topic for your critical essay assignment.

Other times you might be required to choose a topic for yourself. When selecting a topic, it is important to choose one that interests you.

When a topic you are writing about is interesting, you find the research process enjoyable. You will also learn something new in the process.

Writing an interesting topic is easier and enjoyable. When you enjoy researching and writing your topic, you become more engaging with your audience. They will also enjoy reading your work.

Most students prefer picking controversial statements, events, or articles for their critical analysis essay topics. Such research topics are easy to critique. Consider the following points when selecting your critical essay topic

1.     Choose an easy to critically analyze the topic

When searching for a critical essay topic, target one that can easily be critically analyzed. Conduct thorough research and get topic ideas from online databases or your school library.

Talk to your friends and family members and find out which topics generate a lot of debate. You can consider well-known literature or controversial articles that will give you enough reasons and materials to critique.

2.     Select a widely discussed topic

A topic that has different opinions from different people can help you to think deeply about it. You can think outside the box and come up with a unique perspective on the same issue.

This will help make your essay interesting and informative to your audience. It will also help you to develop a strong thesis statement and argument for your paper.

3.     Narrow down your topic

Make sure your topic is not too broad that you cannot comprehensively discuss it in your paper. Some topics can be too wide to fit in an essay and should be narrowed down.

Make your topic focused enough for you to analyze and evaluate it thoroughly. The topic you select should have enough information. It should not be too narrow that you cannot find adequate information or too broad that you cannot manage to cover it entirely.

4.     Reach out to your instructor

You can ask your instructor for direction. For example, your instructor can give you some ideas on how to get the best topics for your critical essay.

He or she can give you prompts that can help you research topics. You can find out where to search and find the best results.

5.     Consider your favorite books

When researching a topic, you have several options, including analyzing your favorite book. Some students enjoy reading books.

This can benefit you if you are one of them. Select a book or an author whose work you enjoy reading.

Make sure his or her work has been analyzed in different ways. This will help you get many materials for references.

It is essential to carefully consider these points when researching a critical essay topic. The following are some critical analysis topic ideas you can consider

  • Discuss the irony in your favorite book
  • Read a literature book and discuss feminist ideology
  • Discuss the things that can affect a writer’s work
  • Discuss a favorite character in a book you like
  • Discuss the components of a captivating drama
  • Discuss the characteristics of your favorite actor in the latest movie you watched
  • Analyze the problems associated with healthy eating habits
  • What are the environmental benefits of recycling waste?

Tips on how to write a critical essay

Writing a compelling critical essay requires you to put into practice your critical thinking skills. You need to examine a source material thoroughly and conduct in-depth research that will help you develop a valuable paper for your audience.

Such skills are developed over time as you continue writing your critical essay assignments. Here are some tips that can help you create a high-quality paper and improve your overall grade.

1.     Smart reading

Critical essay writing is about examining another writer’s work and writing a response. For example, your source material can be in the form of text like a novel, literature book, or scholarly article.

The first thing you must do is to read it in a smart way. Read the text two to three times. The first reading should help you familiarize yourself with the story.

The second and subsequent readings should be critical reading. You should identify details of the text and analyze them. Analyze and take note of the following information.’

  • The author’s thesis and how it is presented to the audience
  • Identify any controversies in the message
  • What values are communicated in the text?
  • What are the weak areas or strong points in the text?

2.     Conduct thorough research

Research similar essays and read them. Find inspiration from them and understand their structure and style. This is important, especially when you are writing a critical analysis essay for the first time.

Do not copy other people’s work but use them as inspiration to develop your own writing style. Introduce your original ideas to your audience and use words you are familiar with. This will help readers understand your writing without struggling to check the meaning of difficult words.

3.     Start your critical essay writing assignment early

Writing a critical analysis essay requires ample time to read the source document, plan, research, write and proofread your work. Starting your critical essay assignment early enables you to have enough time to produce a well-researched and analyzed paper.

Do not wait to start writing your paper at the last minute. When you start late, you will produce a rushed and poorly written document with weak evidence and errors.

This can negatively impact your overall grade. The earlier you start writing your paper, the better the quality and the higher your grade.

4.     Plan well

Always plan your work so that you can get a good outcome. Schedule enough time for research and come up with a structure to help you organize your work.

An essay structure is a laid-out plan on how you intend to analyze your work from the introduction to the conclusion. It involves writing down your major points and the evidence you intend to use when drafting your final essay. This plan will help you remember important facts and draft your paper faster.

5.     Introduce the author and text

The introduction section of your essay should provide background information about your topic and the author’s details. Introduce the author of the work you will be analyzing to your audience.

Provide brief information about the text he or she has written. This gives a reader background information about the author and helps in understanding the forthcoming analysis.

6.      Focus on the author’s work

A critical analysis essay is about looking at another person’s work. Do not focus on yourself so much instead, focus on the work you need to analyze.

When giving your opinion, use third person narrative and provide proof. Make sure you express your views and support them with valid evidence from the text under analysis and your research work. Avoid using words like “I think” or saying “In my opinion.”

7.     Develop your style

When writing your essay, develop your personal writing style. Let your voice be heard in your work instead of copying someone else.

Your language should be formal and clear for your readers to quickly understand your writing. Make sure your workflows logically from one point to the next to avoid confusing your readers.

8.     Provide details

When analyzing your source document, do not assume the reader knows what you mean. Explain everything you are talking about. Give details of particular facts.

Explain the technical terms that you are analyzing. Make sure your readers understand the abbreviations you have used. When you explain each detail in your analysis and evaluation process, you are sure that readers follow your discussion.

9.     Cite your sources

Provide references for quotes or information from other sources that you have used to write your critical essay. Properly cite your sources using the required format. This will help you avoid plagiarism issues.

10.Proofread your work

Allocate enough time to look at your work and make corrections. Do not submit work with grammatical errors and poor sentence structure.

When your paper has mistakes, it causes your work to lack credibility. You can use proofreading software to polish your essay before submitting your final draft.

11.Follow instructions

When writing your critical analysis essay, makes sure you follow all your instructor’s instructions. No matter how good your essay is, you will lose marks if you do not follow provided instructions. Read them carefully and ask your instructor for clarification where you are not sure.

Key takeaway

A critical essay helps you develop critical thinking skills, among other skills that you can use in the future. The more you write a critical analysis paper, the more your skills improve.

This type of essay involves understanding how to analyze and evaluate other people’s work. It requires critical reading, in-depth research, and organized writing to come up with an excellent paper.

You can use various critiquing techniques to evaluate a source document. The technique you choose depends on the outcome you want to achieve.  Back up your personal opinion with evidence. To learn more on critical essays, contact homework writers.

Order NOW For A 10% Discount!
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Our Advantages

Plagiarism Free Papers’s team of writers write all papers from scratch. We deliver 100% original, unique papers. That’s what makes us the best custom homework writing service

Free Revisions

We provide unlimited free revisions to all customers and on all papers. Try The Homework Writings today for the best custom homework writing service and experience in the industry.

Title-page gives clients title pages free of charge. Your only job is to fill out our order form. We will handle the rest.


As the leading essay writing service, we never submit any paper without a reference/bibliography page. We do this free of charge too.

Originality & Security

At, we take great pride in delivering only high-quality 100% original papers to all our clients. We also never share any of our clients’ information with third parties. Your data is safe with us.

24/7 Customer Support

No other custom homework writing service has a friendly, always available customer support team to respond to clients like us.

Try it now!

Calculate the price of your order

We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Why outsource our services

We have the best customer support team for your essay writing needs.


Flexible Pricing

You won’t find any other custom homework writing service with pricing as flexible and affordable as ours.


Admission help & Client-Writer Contact

We provide a direct line of communication with our writers for the best writing experience.


Paper Submission

As the leading custom homework writing service, we take deadlines very seriously. You will have your paper submitted on time without any delays.


Customer Feedback

We truly value your feedback, good or bad, and always use your feedback to help us provide you with an even better custom homework writing service